hen the Yankees brought in 29-year-old utility player Dominic Smith for spring training, it initially seemed like a move to add depth. However, thanks to some well-timed hits and a bit of luck, Smith may have positioned himself for a spot on the roster—something that wasn’t part of the original plan.
Experience Matters to Boone
Manager Aaron Boone places a high value on experience, and Smith has plenty of it. Having played in 693 major league games with over 2,200 plate appearances, he has faced more MLB pitching than some of the younger players competing for the designated hitter role.
The Yankees have been considering options like Ben Rice and J.C. Escarra to help fill the gap left by Giancarlo Stanton’s absence, but Smith’s veteran presence could give him an advantage in the competition.
Strong Spring Performance
Smith has capitalized on his chances this spring, posting a .333/.333/.625 slash line with two home runs and 10 RBIs in nine games. Even more noteworthy is his 12.5% strikeout rate, which indicates he’s consistently making contact—an attribute Boone values highly. While Smith has never been a major power hitter, with a career-high of 12 home runs in a season, his ability to drive in runs and keep the offense moving could make a case for his inclusion on the roster.
Defensive Versatility as a Key Asset
Smith’s ability to play multiple positions also works in his favor. Primarily a first baseman, he has accumulated over 3,000 innings at the position with a strong .992 fielding percentage. This makes him a reliable backup option for Paul Goldschmidt, though Goldschmidt has been remarkably durable, playing at least 150 games in every full season for over a decade.
Additionally, Smith has experience in the outfield, providing Boone with extra flexibility if the team needs coverage in a corner outfield spot. While he may not be a primary choice for that role, his versatility adds value, particularly in a long season where injuries are always a concern.
Can Smith’s Skill Set Secure Him a Roster Spot?
Boone’s decision will likely come down to whether the Yankees prioritize power or contact in the DH role. Smith isn’t known for his power, but he has shown some increased pop this spring, which could play a role in the final roster choices. If the team values on-base ability and consistent contact, Smith stands a strong chance of making the cut. However, if power becomes the main factor, younger options like Rice or Escarra might get the nod instead.
Regardless of the final decision, Smith has done everything possible to make the Yankees reconsider before sending him back down.
