The New York Mets’ strategy involving Brett Baty seems to be shifting, with the potential of him transitioning to a new position. The Mets, struggling with their third base conundrum this season, might consider Baty as a solution at second base.
After being sent to the minors last week, Baty was informed he’d get more practice at second base, though this hasn’t yet occurred, according to Tim Healey of Newsday. As Baty returns to the Mets for the London games against the Phillies, questions about Jeff McNeil’s future with the team intensify.
Baty’s development at second base could signal the beginning of the end for McNeil’s time with the Mets. This season’s spring training saw an intense competition for the third base spot, which Baty initially secured while Mark Vientos was demoted to the minors.
However, Baty’s slump in May allowed Vientos to reclaim the third base position with his impressive performance against Triple-A opponents.
Vientos has potentially solidified his hold on third base for the season with his strong batting and improved defensive skills. Boasting a 1.013 OPS and five home runs in 74 plate appearances, Vientos has made a significant impact.
Consequently, Baty will need to find a different infield position if he hopes to continue playing. With Francisco Lindor at shortstop and Pete Alonso at first base, Baty’s options are limited. Should Alonso depart in the offseason, the Mets might shift Vientos to first base and bring in Ronny Mauricio for third base in 2025.
Baty’s potential position change is also a forewarning for McNeil, who has recently been relegated to a platoon role, starting only against right-handed pitchers.
Since his recent call-up, Jose Iglesias has been taking the starts against left-handed pitchers, amassing seven hits in 18 at-bats. Notably, Baty is also a left-handed hitter, adding to the speculation about McNeil’s future.
Gaining additional experience in Triple-A could benefit Baty, proving his versatility. Having played only 34 games at Triple-A in his career, Baty’s lack of experience at that level might have contributed to his offensive struggles and prolonged slumps in the majors.
Baty, once a top-25 prospect, showcased exceptional performance in Double-A in 2022, which led to rapid promotions to Triple-A and then to the majors within a week.
If the Mets believe Baty can handle second base at the major league level, it might indicate that Jeff McNeil’s tenure with the team is nearing its end. The focus on evaluating players for the next season could mean McNeil isn’t part of the Mets’ long-term plans.
Transitioning Baty to second base could be the optimal solution for the third base congestion between him and Vientos, as the Mets aim to build a younger, more athletic roster moving forward.
