Giancarlo Stanton, the veteran outfielder for the New York Yankees, has long been a player who captivates both fans and analysts. His propensity to occasionally swing at pitches far outside the strike zone is often overshadowed by his ability to send baseballs soaring deep into the night.
Despite experiencing a decline in recent seasons, Stanton’s raw power remains an invaluable asset for the Yankees, serving as a reminder of the prodigious talent that has defined much of his career.
Analyzing Stanton’s 2024 Performance
At 34 years old, Stanton’s 2023 season was notably disappointing, marking the lowest point in his career with a batting average of .191 and a slugging percentage of .420 over 101 games. This season saw him hitting 24 home runs and driving in 60 RBIs, but his weighted runs created plus (wRC+) of 89 indicated a below-average performance for the first time.
However, the 2024 season has been a testament to his resilience and adaptability. Stanton’s power metrics are once again elite, with his bat speed ranking in the 100th percentile and both his average exit velocity and barrel rate in the 99th percentile. These numbers highlight a resurgence in his formidable power-hitting abilities.
Although his whiff and strikeout rates remain high, Stanton has adjusted his approach at the plate. Under the guidance of the Yankees’ coaching staff, he has adopted a more aggressive batting strategy.
This has paid dividends, reflected in a hard-hit rate of 53.8%—his highest since 2021—and a barrel rate of 19.2%, the best since 2019. Over the course of 63 games this season, Stanton has posted a .238 batting average, a .488 slugging percentage, 17 home runs, 40 RBIs, and a 122 wRC+, all of which signify a marked improvement over his performance last year.
The Yankees Need Stanton to Remain Healthy
While Stanton’s offensive prowess remains intact, his defensive contributions have waned, making it imperative for him to stay healthy to continue influencing games with his bat. Stanton’s contract, which runs through 2028 with a $10 million buyout option, ensures his place with the Yankees for the foreseeable future.
However, the rise of promising young talents like Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones may eventually affect his role on the team. Despite these emerging players, Stanton’s ability to deliver in high-pressure situations—evidenced by his .269 average and .537 slugging percentage with runners in scoring position—continues to be a critical asset for the Yankees.
Should the Yankees Pursue Stanton at the Trade Deadline?
The question of whether the Yankees should trade for this versatile veteran bat looms large. While the Yankees are currently benefiting from Stanton’s underrated production, his hefty $98 million contract and diminishing defensive skills complicate the decision. Moreover, the potential need to replace veteran utility infielders adds another layer to the Yankees’ strategic considerations.
Stanton’s performance in clutch moments will be crucial for the Yankees’ postseason ambitions. Despite the necessity for potential adjustments to his aggressive batting style, his presence in the lineup remains vital to the team’s success.
As the Yankees progress through the season, managing Stanton’s health and maximizing his contributions will be essential in their pursuit of a championship. The balance between nurturing emerging talents and leveraging Stanton’s experience and power will define the Yankees’ strategy as they aim for glory.
