In what could become one of the most impactful trades of the MLB season, the New York Yankees are reportedly positioning themselves to land St. Louis Cardinals third baseman Nolan Arenado. Despite the massive $260 million contract Arenado is carrying and his strict no-trade clause, insiders suggest the Yankees could still pull off this blockbuster deal.
Nolan Arenado’s name has consistently surfaced in trade speculation throughout the year, largely because of his elite performance and the Cardinals’ recent struggles. While his expensive contract and no-trade clause have made it difficult for St. Louis to find a viable trade partner, his hot start to the 2025 season could change that. The Yankees, in urgent need of a solid third baseman, appear ready to pounce.
Tim Kelly of Bleacher Report recently predicted that Arenado might waive his no-trade clause for a move to the Bronx. “Arenado does have a pair of seasons remaining on the eight-year, $260 million deal that he signed with the Colorado Rockies,” Kelly explained. “But while he’ll count $25.55 million against the luxury-tax threshold in 2026 and 2027, his deal is backloaded. Arenado will make a more modest $31 million for his age-35 and -36 seasons.”
Kelly added, “It seems like all great Rockies eventually end up spending time with the Yankees, and Arenado would give New York an upgrade over the .705 OPS that Oswaldo Cabrera has produced. This deal would also reunite him with Paul Goldschmidt, as the Yankees try to make a deep playoff run for the second time in as many seasons.”
The Yankees have been aggressively adding pieces to strengthen their playoff aspirations. With a glaring need at third base, the fit seems almost perfect. Additionally, reuniting Arenado with former teammate Paul Goldschmidt could elevate the team’s chemistry and postseason potential.
The main hurdle remains Arenado’s no-trade clause, which he must waive to finalize any deal. However, if he gives the green light, this move could happen quickly—potentially within days.
With the Yankees in win-now mode and the Cardinals looking to reshape their roster, this high-stakes trade could reshape the balance of power in the American League.
